• Breakfast • Lunch • Dinner • Catering • Parties • Events

• Breakfast • Lunch • Dinner • Catering • Parties • Events

November 11th, 2025

Soup $5

Potato cheese

Apertivo $15

Turkish style pizza with spiced pork spread, toped with a red onion, sumac, mint salad & a lemon crema 

Empty restaurant table set with a glass carafe of light-colored juice or cocktail, a wine glass with a pink beverage and ice, a fork on a cloth napkin, and a white plate with a fork and knife. Shadows and sunlight create a moody atmosphere.

If you don’t see what you’re looking for, give us a call at (269) 469-3005

A bowl of pasta with colorful vegetables and garnished with chopped herbs.

Breakfast, lunch, dinner, drinks and more!

Plate of roast meat with gravy, garnished with fresh herbs, with vegetables including corn, carrots, and sausage slices on a white table.

Order times may vary

Physical gift cards are available for purchase in-house

In-house and offsite events and catering!

About Brewsters

Nestled in the heart of downtown New Buffalo, Brewsters is a locally owned restaurant with deep Italian roots, offering a warm and inviting dining experience. Whether you’re savoring a classic cacio e pepe or indulging in a signature cocktail, every bite and sip reflects a commitment to quality and authenticity. With its charming ambiance and genuine hospitality, Brewster’s has become a beloved staple for both locals and visitors seeking a true taste of Italy along the Lake Michigan shoreline.