Nestled in the heart of downtown New Buffalo, Brewsters is a locally owned restaurant with deep Italian roots, offering a warm and inviting dining experience. Whether you’re savoring a classic cacio e pepe or indulging in a signature cocktail, every bite and sip reflects a commitment to quality and authenticity. With its charming ambiance and genuine hospitality, Brewster’s has become a beloved staple for both locals and visitors seeking a true taste of Italy along the Lake Michigan shoreline.